Skip to content

Can I Mix Pennzoil and Valvoline?

Mixing different oil brands, including Pennzoil and Valvoline, is generally not recommended. This is because different oil brands may have various additives that can react with each other and cause problems.

Here are some of the problems that can occur when mixing different brands of oil:

  • The oil may become cloudy or milky.
  • The oil may lose viscosity and become less effective at lubricating the engine.
  • The oil may form deposits in the engine.
  • The oil may cause the engine to overheat.

If you are unsure whether or not it is safe to mix different oil brands, it is always best to consult your car’s owner’s manual. The owner’s manual will specify the type of oil recommended for your car.

If you decide to mix different oil brands, it is important to do so gradually. Start by adding a small amount of the new oil to the old oil, then run the engine for a few minutes. If there are no problems, you can add more of the new oil.

Changing the oil filter when you mix different oil brands is also essential. The oil filter will help to remove any contaminants that may be present in the new oil. By following these tips, you can help minimize the risk of problems when mixing different oil brands.

Understanding the Basics of Engine Oils

Before diving deep into the compatibility of Pennzoil and Valvoline, it’s crucial to have a foundational understanding of what engine oils are made of.

  1. Base Oils: These constitute approximately 70-90% of engine oil and determine its viscosity and basic properties.
  2. Additives: Making up the rest of the oil, additives enhance the oil’s performance by preventing rust, reducing friction, and combating sludge formation.

The Core Characteristics of Pennzoil

Pennzoil, a renowned name in the motor oil industry, is known for its pioneering approach to lubrication technology. Their products are primarily known for:

  • PurePlus Technology: This unique approach involves converting natural gas into crystal-clear base oil with fewer impurities than other traditional oils.
  • Performance Additives: Pennzoil formulations contain additives that actively keep engines clean, ensuring better responsiveness and performance.

Valvoline’s Distinct Features

On the other hand, Valvoline has its rich legacy and stands out for:

  • SynPower Full Synthetic Range: Valvoline boasts its full synthetic range, ensuring superior engine protection against heat, wear, and deposits.
  • Dedicated Additive Packages: Their formulations are curated to provide optimal performance, especially in extreme conditions.

Mixing Pennzoil and Valvoline: The Chemistry Behind

Given Pennzoil’s and Valvoline’s distinct characteristics, mixing them might seem counterintuitive. Here’s the scientific breakdown:

  1. Viscosity Mismatch: Oils with different viscosities might not blend seamlessly. This could lead to inconsistent lubrication, causing potential damage to engine components.
  2. Additive Reaction: The different additive packages in Pennzoil and Valvoline might react, leading to sediment formation or reduced lubrication effectiveness.

However, it’s essential to note that mixing different brands of the same viscosity might not cause immediate harm in emergencies. Yet, consistent use of a single brand is recommended for long-term engine health.

Expert Recommendations and Best Practices

  1. Consistency is Key: While occasional mixing in dire situations might not be catastrophic, it’s always advisable to top up your engine with the same oil brand and type.
  2. Understand Your Engine: Different engines have specific requirements. Refer to the vehicle’s owner manual for the right oil type and brand.
  3. Routine Oil Changes: Ensure regular oil changes at stipulated intervals. This guarantees optimal performance and prevents potential issues arising from prolonged use of mixed oils.


While mixing Pennzoil and Valvoline isn’t the end of the world, it’s not a practice we’d recommend for sustained engine health and performance. Always prioritize consistency, understand your engine’s needs, and adhere to expert recommendations for the best results. An engine is the heart of a vehicle, and using the right oil consistently ensures it beats strongly and efficiently for years to come.